Zappa.com

Gilmour

_________________

Ummagumma,live @ The Fillmore west`69. 1st P.Floyd experience.


vote: both

_________________
I'm getting larger as I walk away.

Syd!

_________________

David Gilmour Momentary Lapse of Reason tour 1987
Roger Waters the Dark Side of the Moon tour 2007 and the Wall tour 2012

I love both of these guys, "thier" music is timeless and has provided the soundtrack to so many great moments throughout my life. Certain passage's of Pink Floyd's music can transport me back in time and induce feelings of euphoria like no other music I have ever heard.
So far there has only been one other artist's music that can move me emotionally, his initials are FZ.

PS I did burst into tears at a David Bowie performance of Space Oddity during the 1983 serious moonlight tour, but to be fair I was very very depressed (woman trouble) and I was very drunk at the time.

I like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUYzQaCCt2o

"Gilmour: Sure, I'll do it. What is the farthest I can be away from Roger and still be on the same stage?"

Ditto

_________________
"I'm interested in the capitalistic way of life, and the reason I like it better than anything else I've seen so far is because competition produces results."

If I choose not to decide I'll still have made a choice.

*update- Gilmour

_________________
*********************************************************************

I go along with Mr GG - Barrett (as I'm sure Gilmour would choose)

_________________
"I have learned from my mistakes, and I am sure I can repeat them exactly."

Gilmour for musicianship

Waters for creativity

Best stuff either of them did was when they were together!

First Waters solo tour blew away anything DG's Pink Floyd did live.

Enjoyed Waters' Dark Side Tour much more than The Wall (saw it, won't be bothering again unless it's free and I don't have anything else to do)

Saw several Momentary shows including some of the first couple--really enjoyed echoes and SOYCD

Division Bell tour bored me (saw two shows in Oakland which are frequently bootlegged)

All shows after the breakup were more Pink Floyd Revue with too many extras (people and bombast) Both camps were guilty of this but the DG PF was worse.
My opinion only!

Now go listen to some early Pink Floyd live

Ummagumma do that right now neurochasm,with only 2 post since`06 and one of them is about PF.

_________________
I'm getting larger as I walk away.

I think that BOTH were vital to Pink Floyd's greatness and they were better together than without one another. Gilmour was the better vocalist and instrumentalist. Waters' was one of the best ever rock lyricists.

However I think that Rick Wright (RIP) should also be mentioned in the conversation. His keyboards were integral to Floyd's sounds and he came up with some key song contributions in his own right. His vox were also excellent. In my opinion, Wright's contributions to Pink Floyd were as important (and under-rated) as George Harrison's to the Beatles.

Definitely Gilmour. One of rock's most distinctive guitarists. Waters is a great lyricist but the more control he took over Floyd, the less I liked their music.

I don't remember where I read this but years ago someone said that Waters and Gilmour had a lot in common with Lennon and McCartney. Lennon and Waters were the ones who made you think but McCartney and Gilmour made you enjoy it.

_________________
Hey, pass me the dog food.

I voted The Beach Boys.

Creatively, you'd have to break it down this way...


For lyric & conceptual writing, Waters.


For writing music and performing, Gilmour (& Wright).

_________________
"...I'm absolutely a Libertarian on MANY issues..." ~ Frank Zappa, Rochester, NY, March 11, 1988

Poor Nick

_________________

Sorry, I don't give a fuck about PF.

_________________
Everytime we picked a booger we'd flip it on this one winduh. Every night we'd contribute, 2, 3, 4 boogers. We had to use a putty knife, man, to get them damn things off the winduh. There was some goober ones that weren't even hard...

Check my Nephew out
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fF5j-_2iUSg
another brick in the wall part 2 solo cover

I told him say that there is a backing track also good stuff sounds like he is playing along too Gilmours Guitar though not i seen Sync guitar port with Sony Vages of just backing track.

_________________
Arf you out of your fucking mind.

Well put...

gilters! no, no, wamour!

_________________
I can't tell when you're telling the truth.
>I'm not.
How do I know anything you've said to me is...
>You don't.

Ha ha. Hopefully I'm not the only one who gets that.

What a stupid question. I swore to myself a long time ago that I was not going to be one of those people who said this about other people's threads. But seriously ... what a really stupid question.

The only reason I don't listen to much Pink Floyd any more is that there isn't much in the first place and when you divide that by two after cherry picking there's even less and I'm so familiar with that half there's almost no point any more. My eldest son had a thing about them a while back which I was chuffed about but he went on to overplay them of course.

Personally, even though they've separated themselves, I can't separate them in my head, it's like the yin and yang of whatever floyd became after Sid left. I think when Sid was with them it was different band and that stuff is dated in my opinion.

Mind you, whatever that quote says about Gilmour's attitude to Waters, he's standing pretty close to him in that pic.

_________________
The way I see it Barry, this should be a very dynamite show.

Ha ha. Hopefully I'm not the only one who gets that.

Well spotted Poly

No need to buy DSotM here,just turn on a classic rock station and there it is! I agree about Sid,I've seen them in`69 all together,playing Ummagumma,way before DSotM came out and it was one of the best concerts ever.(other than FZ) After the break-up I saw the Gilmore pink pig tour/show and it was just like classic radio.Pleasant and nice,but nothing new there.The people on acid or shrooms seemed to enjoy it more.I just wanted to turn the channel! So if Dave,Sid and Roger stayed together,I'd hope they'd have come up with some new shit,together.We'll never know now.But I bet it would have been great!
BTW,back in`69 at the Fillmore,you could barely see the guys,because of the mass of equipment and instruments.Even a six foot wide gong! Who played the gong? Talk about YCFTOSA,Frank would have been very curious as to how it fit and how they got certain sounds out of that configuration of equipment.But y'all knew that already.....didn't you?

_________________
I'm getting larger as I walk away.

Sorry. That never happened. Bruce Johnston and Toni Tenille.

I listened to my 1977 Animals cassette in the car again this morning, and in spite of what most critics say, there's some good keyboard playing by Wright on that album - some fine ELP emulations on Dogs, f'rintance. They must be comparing to WYWH, where he's even more prominent. Plus Mason's drumming is much better than his reputation suggests - very cool rhythms on Dogs, again. Check out the "Just another sad old man" section as a case in point. Overall a wonderful album, and amazing that my old EMI cassette isn't worn out after all these years. I did have to change the sponge a coupla years back, though.

_________________
We make a special art in an environment hostile to dreamers. Frank Zappa, 1971